The Shortlist Is Settled Before the First Call: What That Means for UK Engineering Firms
Updated: 5 days ago
An engineering firm usually finds out it has lost a contract long after the decision was made. Quite often it never finds out at all, because it was never really in the running. Recent research on how B2B buyers choose suppliers suggests that this is the normal state of things, not bad luck.
The 6sense 2025 B2B Buyer Experience Report surveyed nearly 4,000 B2B buyers across North America, Europe and Asia-Pacific, with 20% from the UK and Ireland and 14% working in manufacturing. Its central finding is blunt. 94% of buying groups had put their shortlist in order of preference before speaking to any seller, and the eventual winner came from that day-one shortlist 95% of the time. Buyers spoke first to the supplier they went on to choose in roughly four deals out of five (77% in the main survey, 81% in a companion survey).
Two more figures explain how that shortlist forms. 97% of buyers had prior experience with at least one supplier on it, and 85% had prior experience with the supplier that won. 79% said they, not the seller, made first contact. The report does find first contact happening earlier than before, at around 61% of the way through the buying process compared with 69% in 2024. Even so, most of the thinking is done before anyone picks up the phone.
Some caution is fair here. 6sense sells account-based marketing software, so it has an interest in this story, and the report does not publish its fieldwork dates. Its sample also leans towards technology and services buyers, with typical purchases worth a few hundred thousand dollars. A UK subcontract machining firm quoting for a £40,000 batch job is not the median respondent. Physical goods still made up 26% of the purchases covered, though, and the pattern is hard to dismiss.
Forrester adds the second half of the problem. Its State of Business Buying 2026 research, based on nearly 18,000 business buyers worldwide and published in January, found that a typical purchase now involves 13 internal stakeholders and nine external influencers, and that procurement staff are decision-makers in 53% of buying cycles. 94% of buyers use AI somewhere in the process, but Forrester notes they still check what it tells them against people and sources they trust.
Put those findings side by side and "brand" starts to mean something more practical for a technical SME. It is not a logo refresh or a new tagline. It is whether the design engineer, the operations manager, the procurement lead and the outside consultant on that buying group have each come across your firm, and come away with a clear idea of what you are good at, before the request for quote goes out. Prior experience can be a past job. It can also be a useful article, a talk at a trade event, a straight answer on a datasheet or a recommendation from a colleague. If a buyer's first real contact with you is your quote, there is a fair chance you are being used to check the favourite's price.
For most engineering and manufacturing firms the gaps are familiar. The website explains what the company is rather than which problems it solves. There is little that an engineer or a buyer could forward to colleagues. The people who actually know the technical detail are invisible online. And when a buyer asks an AI tool for possible suppliers, there is nothing specific enough for it to pick up, which is the same issue we covered in B2B buyers fact-check AI research before they trust it.
Nebula's work with technical SMEs starts at that early stage. We look at what a buyer can learn about you before they ever get in touch, then close the gaps: clear positioning, proof such as case studies, technical content that different members of a buying group can actually use, and a steady presence in the places your buyers already look. None of that guarantees a place on every shortlist. It does make it far less likely that you are left off one you should have been on.




Comments